Now taking reservations through Opentable!
Pizza and Pasta on Fifth – Authentic NY-Style Pizza & Italian Comfort Food in the Gaslamp
At Pizza and Pasta on Fifth, we’re all about serving real New York-style pizza the way it’s meant to be – thin, foldable crusts with the perfect char, topped with premium ingredients and melted mozzarella that stretches with every bite. But we’re more than just pizza! Our expanded menu now features homemade pastas, crisp salads, and Italian classics – all made with the same commitment to quality that’s made us a Gaslamp favorite.
Family is at our core – from how we treat our team to the welcoming vibe we create for every customer. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice after a convention, sitting down for a hearty plate of spaghetti and meatballs, or fueling up for a night out in downtown San Diego, we’re here to serve food that hits the spot.
Late-night slices • Whole pies • Pasta dishes • Salads
Open late to satisfy your cravings!
Starters & Salads
Pizza
Sandwiches & Paninis
Desserts
Pasta
Drinks
Get our food delivered to you!
Check out our Happy Hour specials!
Follow us @PizzaOn5th
Latest News
Where to Eat After a Padres Game in San Diego
Pizza on 5th at 734 5th Avenue is the closest full-menu restaurant to Petco Park in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter, open until 3AM or 4AM every night. This article covers how to get there after a Padres game, what to order, parking tips, and why it’s the most practical answer to post-game hunger in downtown San Diego.
The Best Late Night Pizza and Food in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter
Pizza on 5th serves NY-style pizza and Italian comfort food at 734 5th Avenue in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter, open until 3AM Sunday through Thursday and 4AM on Friday and Saturday. This guide covers why it’s the go-to spot for late night pizza in San Diego and how a full kitchen running until close sets it apart from every other option in the neighborhood.
Best Margarita Deals in Downtown San Diego Every Thursday at Pizza on 5th
Looking for the best margarita deals in downtown San Diego? Every Thursday brings $9 traditional, elderflower, strawberry, and signature margaritas from 12pm to 9pm. Skip the typical happy hour windows and enjoy consistent pricing all day long. Four different margarita styles, extended hours, and downtown location make Thursday the best day for affordable tequila cocktails in San Diego.
Why Prosciutto Makes Pizza Better: The Science Behind the Perfect Topping
Prosciutto transforms pizza with its salty-sweet flavor and delicate texture. This dry-cured Italian ham adds complexity without overwhelming other toppings, creating the perfect balance on every slice.
San Diego Gluten Free Pizza Worth the Trip Downtown
A guide to finding quality gluten free pizza in San Diego, including what to ask, what to look for, and where to find options downtown and in the Gaslamp Quarter.
Why Nutella Pizza Is the Dessert You Didn’t Know You Needed
Nutella pizza transforms a classic savory dish into an unforgettable sweet experience. This dessert combines warm, crispy pizza dough with rich chocolate-hazelnut spread, creating a treat that satisfies both pizza lovers and dessert enthusiasts. Unlike traditional…
Where to Eat After a Padres Game in San Diego
Pizza on 5th at 734 5th Avenue is the closest full-menu restaurant to Petco Park in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter, open until 3AM or 4AM every night. This article covers how to get there after a Padres game, what to order, parking tips, and why it’s the most practical answer to post-game hunger in downtown San Diego.
The Best Late Night Pizza and Food in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter
Pizza on 5th serves NY-style pizza and Italian comfort food at 734 5th Avenue in San Diego’s Gaslamp Quarter, open until 3AM Sunday through Thursday and 4AM on Friday and Saturday. This guide covers why it’s the go-to spot for late night pizza in San Diego and how a full kitchen running until close sets it apart from every other option in the neighborhood.
Best Margarita Deals in Downtown San Diego Every Thursday at Pizza on 5th
Looking for the best margarita deals in downtown San Diego? Every Thursday brings $9 traditional, elderflower, strawberry, and signature margaritas from 12pm to 9pm. Skip the typical happy hour windows and enjoy consistent pricing all day long. Four different margarita styles, extended hours, and downtown location make Thursday the best day for affordable tequila cocktails in San Diego.
